One More BookFind a book
Series Horror ages 9–12

Crater Lake

Part of the collectionCrater Lake
Grows with the reader

A two-book gateway-horror thrill ride — creepy, funny and relentlessly paced, with the scares escalating from the first book to a scarier, cleverer sequel.

  • Books2 / 2
  • Arcs1
  • Span2020–2021
  • StatusComplete
Start hereCrater LakeBook 1 · 2020 · the natural entry to the series
Open

The series

At a glance.

Jennifer Killick's Crater Lake duology takes an alien body-snatcher premise and runs it at full pelt: fall asleep and you wake up wrong, blank-eyed and taken over from the inside. The first book strands Lance and his friends at a remote residential centre; the second brings an evolved, cleverer version of the threat home to his own town, with one of the aliens wearing his mother's face. Killick keeps the humour and heart intact while steadily turning up the dread, so the fright escalates across the two books. Short chapters, cliffhanger pacing and a genuinely funny voice make it exceptionally reluctant-reader friendly, while the creepy imagery and peril place it firmly at the top of the middle-grade age band.

A two-book gateway-horror thrill ride — creepy, funny and relentlessly paced, with the scares escalating from the first book to a scarier, cleverer sequel.

Primary themes

Overall tone

  • Scary
  • Funny
  • Suspenseful
  • Exciting
Reading order

Read Crater Lake before Crater Lake: Evolution — the sequel follows directly on from the first.

One arc

The shape of the series.

  1. I
    Narrative arcBooks 1–2 · 2020–2021Moderate sensitivity

    The alien invasion

    Two connected books escalating an alien body-snatcher threat from a school trip to Lance's home town.

    The two Crater Lake books form a single escalating story. In the first, Lance and his gang are trapped at a remote activity centre where the golden rule is not to fall asleep; in the second, set five months later, an evolved version of the enemy returns to his own town with the friendships now fractured and the stakes personal. The threat gets cleverer and the dread deeper across the pair, so publication order matters. Killick keeps the trademark wisecracking humour and warmth running underneath the horror, so the fear never tips into bleakness. Scary imagery and cartoon-adjacent violence keep it to the top of the age band and away from sensitive or bedtime readers.

    Best fit

    9–12

    Reads as

    • Scary
    • Funny
    • Suspenseful
    • Exciting

    On the page

    • Scary imagery
    • Violence

Fit check

Right for your reader?

Where the series lands by age

  • 1
  • 3
  • 5
  • 7
  • 9
  • 11
  • 13
  • 15
  • 17
  • 19
  • Best fit · 9–12
  • Read aloud · 8–11
  • Independent · 9–12

Reluctant-reader friendliness

Very high

Read-aloud quality

Strong

Adult crossover

Low

Grows with the reader

Designed to

Sensitivity envelope

Moderate overall, and consistent.

ModerateSeries-level

Content notes

  • Scary imagery
  • Violence

Where it sits

In conversation with other series.

Similar in feel

Different shelves, same wavelength.

About the author

Jennifer Killick.

Jennifer Killick

Author

Jennifer Killick: the reigning name in funny-scary middle-grade horror, whose Crater Lake and Dread Wood series pair genuine chills with laugh-out-loud banter — reluctant-reader catnip for 9–12s who like to read, scream, repeat.

More from Jennifer Killick
Last reviewed · July 2026How we recommend

More ways to wander the room