One More BookFind a book
Cover of Whale, That Was Unexpected
Picture · ages 3–7

Whale, That Was Unexpected

Written by Casey Lyall · Illustrated by Kathryn Durst

Adults love it tooEndlessly rereadable

When crusty fisherwoman Maude and her dog Claude are swallowed by a whale, Maude simply throws a farewell party, then keeps rewriting the guest list as more creatures tumble in. A cumulative, fourth-wall-breaking read-aloud with bags of dry wit.

  • Best for3–7
  • FormatPicture
  • Length48 pp
  • Read aloud~10 min
Where to buyPaperback
Amazon
See price at Amazon
Buy

Affiliate links — buy through these retailers and we earn a small commission, at no extra cost to you.

The vibe

What it’s like.

Style

  • Rhyming
  • Comedic
  • Conversational

Tone

  • Funny
  • Silly
  • Whimsical
  • Absurdist

Themes

On the pagewhales, the sea, fishing, parties, sea creatures

Experience meters

Energy4/ 5
Humour5/ 5
Scariness1/ 5
Peril1/ 5
Wonder2/ 5
Cosiness2/ 5
Emotional intensity1/ 5
Conceptual intensity1/ 5

What’s it about?

The story.

Every day, weather-beaten fisherwoman Maude and her scruffy dog Claude head out to sea in their bright yellow waterproofs, and every day is much the same, until the morning their little boat is swallowed whole by a whale. Unfazed, Maude decides that if this is the end, they may as well throw a farewell party. But no sooner has she made her plans than another creature is gulped down to join them: a crab, an octopus, a musty little goat, a sea lion, a puffin, each new arrival forcing Maude to change the party all over again, and to have a few sharp words with the narrator about how her story is being told. Casey Lyall's spirited, cumulative rhyming text crackles with deadpan, fourth-wall-breaking humour, while Kathryn Durst's charcoal-and-gouache illustrations give Maude and Claude enormous personality. A gloriously silly, star-reviewed sea story with attitude, made for lively, laugh-out-loud reading aloud.

Fit check

Right for your child?

Where it lands by age

A high-energy, laugh-out-loud read-aloud for 3-7s, with the wordplay rewarding new readers to about 8. There is no real peril despite the whale, so it suits most listeners, though its noisy comedy makes it a daytime romp rather than a wind-down bedtime story.

  • 1
  • 3
  • 5
  • 7
  • 9
  • 11
  • 13
  • Best fit · 3–7
  • Read aloud · 3–7
  • Independent · 5–8

Prose load

Light

Visual support

Very high

Reluctant-reader friendly

Very

Read-aloud quality

Excellent

Works well for

  • Reading aloud
  • Reading together
  • Reluctant readers
Low sensitivityNo content warnings

Nothing in the book is likely to concern most parents. Safe to recommend without preview.

Bedtime suitability

2 / 5 · Better outside bedtime

Sensitive-child

4 / 5 · Good fit

Graphic intensity

1 / 5 · None

Best for

  • Funny read aloud
  • Silly stories
  • Sea adventures
  • Animal lovers

Avoid if

  • Wants calm bedtime
  • Wants gentle quiet story

Why it lands

Why they love it.

Why kids love it

The daft idea of being swallowed by a whale and deciding to have a party is instantly funny, and the joy of guessing which creature will tumble in next keeps the giggles building. Best of all, Maude keeps bossing the narrator around, which children find hilarious.

  • Surviving danger
  • Trickery and cleverness

Why parents love it

The cumulative rhyme and Maude's deadpan arguments with the narrator make this a performer's dream to read aloud, with plenty of dry wit pitched at the grown-up too. Durst's characterful art and the guess-the-next-guest structure earn it a spot in the repeat pile.

  • Shared humour
  • Quick to read
  • Beautiful illustrations

About the creators

About the creators.

CL

Casey Lyall

Writer · Canada

Casey Lyall is a Canadian author who lives and works at her local library in south-western Ontario, writing warm, funny books for children across picture books and middle grade. Her picture book Whale, That Was Unexpected, illustrated by Kathryn Durst, is a gloriously silly cumulative sea story: when the crusty fisherwoman Maude and her scruffy dog Claude are swallowed whole by a whale, Maude simply decides to throw a farewell party, only to keep rewriting the guest list as a crab, an octopus, a goat and more tumble in after them. Lyall's spirited rhyming text crackles with deadpan wit and cheeky fourth-wall-breaking asides, as Maude has a few sharp words with the narrator about how her story is being told. A star-reviewed, laugh-out-loud read-aloud with bags of personality and attitude.

More from Casey Lyall
KD

Kathryn Durst

Illustrator · Canada

Kathryn Durst is a Canadian illustrator, a Sheridan College graduate and former Pixar intern based in Toronto, whose lively, character-rich art has brought a string of picture books to life, including Paul McCartney's Hey Grandude! She illustrates Casey Lyall's Whale, That Was Unexpected (2026), a cumulative, fourth-wall-breaking sea story in which a crusty fisherwoman and her scruffy dog are swallowed by a whale and simply decide to throw a farewell party, rewriting the guest list as more creatures tumble in. Her charcoal-and-gouache illustrations give the pair enormous personality in a gloriously silly, laugh-out-loud read-aloud. A dependable, warm-and-funny picture-book illustrator for ages 3-7.

More from Kathryn Durst

If you liked this

Three ways out of this book.

If you liked this, try…

Lateral matches. Same shelf, different texture.

Cover of The Snail and the Whale
The Snail and the Whale

by Julia Donaldson

There's a Whale in My Bath
Tom and Tony Fletcher
There's a Whale in My Bath

by Tom and Tony Fletcher

Whale in a Bathtub
Kylie Westaway
Whale in a Bathtub

by Kylie Westaway

Last reviewed · July 2026Suggest a correctionHow we recommend

More ways to wander the room